Brian Matthew Griffeth

Sources

1. Florida family of 4 abused 'illiterate' foster and adopted children who don't even know their own birthdays: Police, MSN, July 25, 2025.
2. Griffeth-Warrant, Law & Crime [Document Cloud], July 25, 2025.
3. Columbia County family accused of treating children 'as slaves' have case dropped, First Coast News, November 2, 2025.

• 1. Florida family of 4 abused 'illiterate' foster and adopted children who don't even know their own birthdays: Police

  • 25 Jul 2025
  • News article
  • MSN

  • original
  • archived
  • back to list

  A Florida family of four is behind bars after subjecting their adopted and foster children to myriad forms of abuse, law enforcement in the Sunshine State allege.

  Brian Griffeth, 47, Jill Griffeth, 41, and their biological children, Dallin Griffeth, 21, and Liberty Griffeth, 19, stand accused of various counts of aggravated child abuse, Columbia County court records show.

  Authorities began investigating after one of the children was allegedly caught with a "Taser" at a Mormon church camp in Branford – a tiny town located roughly 45 miles northwest of Gainesville.

  The child's parents allegedly insisted the Taser "was fake and a toy" – but law enforcement determined the device was an actual weapon, according to an arrest warrant obtained by Law&Crime.

  A follow-up visit with a church employee relayed disturbing allegations about the family and the nine children in their home.

  Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

  The church employee told child welfare authorities the family had recently relocated from Arizona to Florida with several foster children in tow.

  "[The employee] explained that the Griffeth family primarily fosters or adopts African American children and expressed concerns that these foster/adoptive children are being treated unfairly," the arrest warrant reads. "[The employee] indicated that the children are not receiving proper education, as none of the foster or adopted children are familiar with their last names or basic personal information. [Child welfare authorities] reported that [the church employee] believes that these foster/adoptive children act as worker[s], not family members."

  As the investigation ramped up, so did the allegations.

  Next, child welfare authorities visited the Griffeth home on Boundary Way in an unincorporated part of Columbia County. At first, Jill Griffeth would not allow investigators to enter the residence or speak with the children, according to the warrant.

  Eventually, the mother relented, allowing interviews with the children while she and her husband supervised, authorities say.

  During these initial interviews, however, some of the "children were unfamiliar with their birthdates" and Jill Griffeth "had to correct them or looked up the information on her phone," according to the court document. Then, the defendant allegedly shut the interviews down and "expressed a desire to consult with her attorney before further questioning."

  One other thing stood out to the initial investigators – a child "who was expected to be present" was "unaccounted for," according to the warrant. When the parents were asked about this apparent discrepancy, Jill Griffeth allegedly said the girl had never been to Florida – but one of her children corrected her. As it turned out, the girl had been with the family in 2024 until she called her mother, who lives in Arizona, "begging her to come get her," the warrant alleges.

  In a heavily redacted section of the court document, the Arizona-based woman relayed allegations of at least one adult committing sexual assault against at least one child in the Griffeth household.

  Another section of the document alleges Brian Griffeth beats the foster and adopted children with a cane "but is careful not to leave a mark."

  The Griffeths are also alleged to treat their foster and adopted children differently in terms of food, according to one witness.

  "[She] reported that if there wasn't enough food, the foster and adopted children in the home would not get any food," the warrant reads.

  The warrant goes on to note the Griffeths have five biological children, three adopted children, and one foster child.

  The children were removed from the home in early July.

  Initial interviews with the children did not result in allegations, according to the warrant. Then, one 14-year-old boy, during a therapy session, alleged that he is sometimes "caged in his bunk bed at home as punishment."

  In a follow-up interview with a Columbia County Sheriff's Office detective, the boy alleged a routine where his parents would use a piece of plywood to cover up the only entrance to the bottom tier of his three-tiered bunk bed – even at night – often making him wait until the next morning if he had to use the bathroom, according to the warrant.

  The boy then alleged harsher punishment.

  From the warrant, at length:

  [The boy] also reported that his mother occasionally asks him to scooch out of his bed and lie on the floor, during which she presses the plywood sheet onto his chest and back as a form of punishment, resulting in splinters that cause injury. [The boy] lifted his shirt and pointed to several scars from this punishment. [The boy] explained that on one occasion, when he was banging on the plywood to be released, his mother unscrewed the plywood, leading him to believe he would be freed. However, she then instructed him to lie back down and pressed the plywood onto his chest, followed by having him turn over so she could press it onto his back before securing him back in his bed.

  While talking about punishments [the boy] also indicated that he has been sprayed in the face with Vinegar.

  The two other occupants of the three-tiered bunk bed – a 9-year-old and 7-year-old – told essentially the same story to investigators.

  The 14-year-old boy is confined to his bed most of the day and night, according to the children cited in the warrant. The 14-year-old is allegedly only released for lunch, dinner, "whenever he wants to play," and sometime on his brothers' request. The adults in the house allegedly use a green drill to secure the plywood and keep the 14-year-old confined because he has "a tendency to steal."

  One of the boys added that his allegedly caged brother "likes it in his bed and sleeps a lot."

  Later, a 14-year-old and 15-year-old girl confirmed the cage-like nature of the bed and how plywood is affixed with the green drill. The younger girl, however, when asked to justify the confinement, said her brother was being punished because "he is too rough with the dogs."

  The 14-year-old girl also "reported being uncertain of her current grade level and indicated that she has not attended school for six or seven years" and "also mentioned that she is illiterate." She went on to tell investigators her mother also used vinegar as punishment against her – recounting an incident in which she was "sprayed before bed by her mother and how the vinegar burned her eyes making her cry herself to sleep."

  The 15-year-old girl allegedly confirmed another different between the adopted and foster children versus the biological children – the provision of cellphones. The older girl said the Griffeths gave cellphones to their biological children but not to the adopted and foster children.

  "[The 15-year-old girl] explained that she's asked for a phone but her mother said she has to learn to read before she can get a phone," the warrant goes on.

  All four defendants are currently being detained in the Columbia County Jail without bond.

  The post 'Careful not to leave a mark': Florida family of 4 abused 'illiterate' foster and adopted children who don't even know their own birthdays, police say first appeared on Law & Crime.

• 2. Griffeth-Warrant

  • 25 Jul 2025
  • News article
  • Law & Crime [Document Cloud]

  • original
  • archived
  • back to list

  [10-page document]

• 3. Columbia County family accused of treating children 'as slaves' have case dropped

  • 2 Nov 2025
  • News article
  • First Coast News

  • original
  • archived
  • back to list

  State Attorney John Durrett said there was a series of "blame shifting, finger pointing, and outright denials of matters" from DCF employees deposed in the case.

  Published: 4:35 PM EDT November 1, 2025
  Updated: 4:03 PM EST November 2, 2025

  COLUMBIA COUNTY, Fla — A Columbia County family of four accused of abusing children and treating them like slaves was released from jail Friday after having their charges dropped, according to court and jail records.

  Brian Griffeth, his wife, Jill, and their two adult children, Dallin and Liberty, have been freed from jail after facing allegations of child abuse. Brian, Dallin and Liberty were each charged with one count of aggravated child abuse, while Jill was charged with three counts of aggravated child abuse.

  John Durrett, state attorney for the Third Judicial Circuit of Florida, explained in a notice that in several depositions in which Florida Department of Children and Families employees were interviewed, there was a series of "blame shifting, finger pointing, and outright denials of matters contained within the initial reports and response."

  Durrett said in the notice that the allegations of the children being treated like slaves and sexually abused were "salacious gossip" and determined to be "unfounded" in DCF's investigation.
  Initial allegations

  According to the Columbia County Sheriff's Office, on July 3, deputies were called to assist DCF with a court-ordered pickup of nine children at the family's home in Fort White.

  Of the nine children, the sheriff's office said five are Brian and Jill's biological children, while the four others — ranging from ages seven to 16 — were adopted.

  CCSO said the pickup order was issued following the outcome of DCF's investigation, which started after a woman who worked at the family's church reported to DCF that one of the Griffeth's children had a taser.

  "Additional concerns were raised about the adopted children being treated unfairly compared to the Griffeths biological children, in addition to the children not knowing their full name or their own birthdays," CCSO said in a release.

  Prior to the pickup order, CCSO said DCF investigators visited the Griffeths' home to interview the family about the accusations. During the visit, investigators observed the Griffeths' biological children playing or watching TV, while the adopted children were working on chores, according to CCSO.

  When DCF investigators interviewed the Griffeths' children, CCSO said "various forms of child abuse were discovered." According to the sheriff's office, accusations of Brian beating the adopted children with a cane and them being locked in their bedrooms were made.

  During a set of interviews with the children, CCSO said they alleged the following:

  They were caged under a modified bunk bed
  They were forced to lie on the floor and let Jill place a sheet of plywood on top of their bodies, pressing down on them, resulting in splinters
  They were being sprayed in the face with vinegar
  They had been given non-prescribed medication
  They had been told to lie about what happens at the home
  They were not being taken to or provided with schooling

  Brian, Jill, Dallin and Liberty were arrested on July 22.
  Issues with the allegations

  The court document detailing the dropping of the charges referenced issues with the allegations of "unlawful caging." Although the full given reasoning behind the confinement of the child was redacted, the state attorney said they could not refute an argument in court that the family was addressing the child's behavior in a way they believed to be necessary to protect their other children from violence.

  The state attorney also wrote that the vinegar spray was determined to be a diluted, homemade version of "Sassy Spray," used as a modern substitution for disciplinary soap in the mouth.

  "Said action does not constitute child abuse," wrote the state attorney.