Convicted:
Ongoing, - Mission:
unknown
Alleged:
1, Multiple victims, unknown, Unknown number of victims,
Alleged crime scenes:
pool, scuba class, swimming, teaching,
Criminal case(s): Ongoing,
Alleged church actions: unknown,
updated Nov 15, 2026 - request update | add info
David Butt was a Mormon in Sandy, Utah.
In September 2024, Butt was CHARGED WITH:
-aggravated sexual abuse of a child
-aggravated sexual abuse of a child
-aggravated sexual abuse of a child
-aggravated sexual abuse of a child
According to news reports, the P.C. Affidavit Butt reports state Butt was a scuba instructor that weekly sexually assaulted a 10-year-old female student, throughout the month in February 2021.
According to reports there may have been other victims. Children that were interviewed told officers that Butt was “much more hands-on” with the girl then the other students. The P.C. Affidavit reports his behavior was described as “creepy”. According to news reports the female victim was diagnosed with PTSD as a result of Butt’s alleged abuse. KUTV
It has been reported by someone familiar with Butt’s case that he is due back in court November 2026.
If you have any information about Butt’s LDS membership history please contact us.
Have any info on this case? Contact FLOODLIT.
Reader-funded investigative journalism
Help us raise money
FLOODLIT needs to raise funds to cover immediate operating bills and keep our independent newsroom running.
If this case report, our source documents, or our database have been useful to you, please help us.
Donate now →FLOODLIT is 100% reader-funded. Every amount helps.
Sources
- Scuba instructor charged with aggravated sexual abuse of juvenile student,
- Sandy scuba instructor indicted on 4 counts of sexual abuse of child ,
- Sandy Scuba Instructor Indicted on Child Sexual Abuse Charges Amid Growing Allegations,
- Sandy scuba instructor charged with sexually abusing young student,
- Utah scuba instructor charged with sexually abusing young student,
- Utah scuba instructor charged with sexually abusing young student ,
-
1. Scuba instructor charged with aggravated sexual abuse of juvenile student
SANDY, Utah (KUTV) — A scuba instructor was charged after being accused of touching his juvenile student inappropriately over the course of a four-week class.
According to the charges, this isn't the first time he's been accused of sexually assaulting a juvenile student, indicating there may be other victims.
David L. Butt, 41, was charged Tuesday with four first-degree felony counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child, and an arrest warrant was issued for his arrest.
Butt was arrested and booked Wednesday, according to court documents.
According to an investigator's probable cause statement, the now-14-year-old told police that Butt -- who was her scuba instructor -- sexually assaulted her in February 2021.
The victim was 10 years old at the time.
The victim reported Butt placed his hands inside her bathing suit and touched her genitals.
She told police that she was forced to swim away from the instructor to put an end to the touching, according to the affidavit.
Charging documents indicate the sexual abuse happened during each week's instructions throughout the month of February.
Officers interviewed another juvenile participant in the scuba class, who described Butt's behavior as "creepy," according to the probable cause statement.
The juvenile also told officers Butt was "much more hands-on" with the girl than the other students, to the point he became concerned and told his father.
Additional AccusationsA request for a no-bail warrant filed in the case noted the juvenile in Salt Lake County may not be the only potential victim.
"There have been additional allegations against the defendant that are similar in nature," the request states.
Court documents noted that a juvenile student in Wasatch County had accused Butt of similar abuse during a training course at the Utah Crater at Homestead Resort in Midway.
"That female minor has suffered immense trauma from the incident and has been diagnosed with PTSD," according to the warrant request.
The document didn't specify when the alleged abuse in Midway happened.
As of the most recent update of this article, no documents relating to Butt had been filed out of Wasatch County.
-
2. Sandy scuba instructor indicted on 4 counts of sexual abuse of child
SANDY, Utah (ABC4) — A Sandy scuba instructor has been indicted on four counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child after he was accused of sexually abusing a former student, according to the Salt Lake County District Attorney.
David L. Butt, 41, was charged on Tuesday in the Third District Court after a former student reported being sexually assaulted by him when she was about 10 years old.
The state of child abuse in Utah, and what we can do about itDocuments state the charges stem from multiple incidents in February of 2021 when the minor told authorities that she was being touched inappropriately by Butt, who was instructing her. Police also interviewed another participant in the class who said Butt was more “hands-on” with the victim than other students.
The same student also stated Butt’s behavior was “creepy.”
“This fellow student was concerned about Butt’s conduct toward [the minor] and told his father about his worries,” documents state.
Charging documents did not specify where he was working when this happened.
No further information is available at this time.
An arrest and/or charges are allegations only. All arrested persons are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt
-
3. Sandy Scuba Instructor Indicted on Child Sexual Abuse Charges Amid Growing Allegations
A Sandy scuba instructor, David L. Butt, stands indicted on four counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child. Prosecutors allege Butt, 41, abused a former student when she was about 10 years old during classes he taught in February of 2021, as reported by ABC4.
The indictments come after the victim disclosed to authorities that Butt touched her inappropriately, with another class participant corroborating the behavior, describing Butt as significantly more "hands-on" with the victim compared to others, according to KUTV. Another juvenile in the class, troubled by Butt's conduct, reported his actions as "creepy" and took his concerns to his father.
Sim Gill, the Salt Lake County District Attorney, highlighted the vulnerability of children in these scenarios, where power dynamics and trust can be exploited. Gill said, as per KSLTV, "We know that with position of power dynamic and unique trust, it also brings that authority into that (alleged abuse) and so children are far more vulnerable."
Further complicating the case, additional allegations of similar nature against Butt have emerged. This includes another young girl who took lessons from Butt in Midway and has since been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder due to the abuse. "These children are not alone, this is not your fault, and we want you to know that as a community we are here to help. And we will take any allegations seriously," Gill said, as obtained by KSLTV.
The current charges involve only the incidents concerning the 10-year-old girl in Salt Lake County, but with a wider investigation underway, there may be more revelations to come as this troubling case unfolds.
-
4. Sandy scuba instructor charged with sexually abusing young student
SALT LAKE CITY — A Sandy scuba instructor is facing felony charges accusing him of sexually abusing a young student.
David L. Butt, 40, was charged Tuesday in 3rd District Court with four counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child, a first-degree felony.
In February of 2021, a 10-year-old alleges "she was sexually assaulted by her scuba instructor," Butt. The girl says Butt would repeatedly place his hand inside her bathing suit and she would try to swim away, according to charging documents. "This happened each week that (the girl) had scuba lessons."
"Officers interviewed another (child) participant of the class, who described the behavior of Butt as 'creepy,' and said that Butt was much more hands on with (the girl) than the other students," according to the charges.
That other student was concerned enough about the behavior, he told a parent about it, the charges state.
Prosecutors also noted there "have been additional allegations against (Butt) that are similar in nature," including from a girl who says Butt did the same thing to her when she took lessons in Midway, according to the charges. "That female minor has suffered immense trauma from the incident and has been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder."
The charges filed Tuesday are for alleged incidents only involving the 10-year-old girl in Salt Lake County.
-
5. Utah scuba instructor charged with sexually abusing young student
SALT LAKE CITY (KSL.com) — A Sandy scuba instructor is facing felony charges accusing him of sexually abusing a young student.
David L. Butt, 40, was charged Tuesday in 3rd District Court with four counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child, a first-degree felony.
In February of 2021, a 10-year-old alleges “she was sexually assaulted by her scuba instructor,” Butt. The girl says Butt would repeatedly place his hand inside her bathing suit and she would try to swim away, according to charging documents. “This happened each week that (the girl) had scuba lessons.”
“Officers interviewed another (child) participant of the class, who described the behavior of Butt as ‘creepy,’ and said that Butt was much more hands on with (the girl) than the other students,” according to the charges.
That other student was concerned enough about the behavior, he told a parent about it, the charges state.
Prosecutors also noted there “have been additional allegations against (Butt) that are similar in nature,” including from a girl who says Butt did the same thing to her when she took lessons in Midway, according to the charges. “That female minor has suffered immense trauma from the incident and has been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder.”
The charges filed Tuesday are for alleged incidents only involving the 10-year-old girl in Salt Lake County.
-
6. Utah scuba instructor charged with sexually abusing young student
SALT LAKE CITY (KSL.com) — A Sandy scuba instructor is facing felony charges accusing him of sexually abusing a young student.
David L. Butt, 40, was charged Tuesday in 3rd District Court with four counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child, a first-degree felony.
In February of 2021, a 10-year-old alleges “she was sexually assaulted by her scuba instructor,” Butt. The girl says Butt would repeatedly place his hand inside her bathing suit and she would try to swim away, according to charging documents. “This happened each week that (the girl) had scuba lessons.”
“Officers interviewed another (child) participant of the class, who described the behavior of Butt as ‘creepy,’ and said that Butt was much more hands on with (the girl) than the other students,” according to the charges.
That other student was concerned enough about the behavior, he told a parent about it, the charges state.
Prosecutors also noted there “have been additional allegations against (Butt) that are similar in nature,” including from a girl who says Butt did the same thing to her when she took lessons in Midway, according to the charges. “That female minor has suffered immense trauma from the incident and has been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder.”
The charges filed Tuesday are for alleged incidents only involving the 10-year-old girl in Salt Lake County.
Documents
Have docs or info? Add information
Criminal case documents
Floodlit does not have a copy of a related probable cause affidavit. Please check back soon or contact us to request that we look for one.Civil case documents
Floodlit does not have a copy of a related civil complaint. Please check back soon or contact us to request that we look for one.Other documents
Floodlit does not have a copy of any other related documents. Please check back soon or contact us to request that we look for some.Add information
If someone you know was harmed by the person listed on this page, or if you would like us to add or correct any information, please fill out the form below. We will keep you anonymous. You can also contact us directly.
"*" indicates required fields

Alleged crime city:
Alleged crime county:
Alleged crime state:


